“We women must realize how visual men are, and because of that we should wear modest clothes. Not because we don’t have the right to wear what we want, but for the benefit of the spiritual life of our brothers in Christ.”
~ Heather Arnel Paulsen, Emotional Purity: An Affair of the Heart
Before leaving on my mission trip to Haiti, I participated in several ”In ‘Other’ Words.” I actually enjoyed the weekly challenge. I felt kind of like I was participating in a virtual impromptu speech that challenged my thinking and writing skills. I was disappointed to learn that the weekly “In ‘Other’ Words” was changed to an every other week event for the summer. I couldn’t keep the schedule straight. Besides, we had tried to do year round school last year. We were still studying Roman history when the busyness of summer began to fill up our free time. So, I decided to take a break from “In ‘Other’ Words” and come back in the fall. Well, October is almost over and I am just getting back. Settling back into school was difficult this year. My blogging has suffered. But, equally important, I drew a blank on many of the quotes that were presented. Perhaps, I should have taken one more week off, because I don’t agree with this weeks quote. I don’t want to teach my daughter that modesty is a negative commandment whose main purpose is to prevent sexual sin.
My daughter likes musicals. Likes is actually an understatement. My daughter obsesses over musicals. Her iPod is filled with soundtracks from Broadway shows. She knows the names of the writers and directors, the year they opened, how long they ran, many of the major vocalists. In voice lessons, she prefers to work on songs from musicals. One of her favorite soundtracks is Aida and her favorite song on that soundtrack is “My Strongest Suit.”
In life one has to face a huge assortment
of nauseating fads and good advice
there’s health and fitness
Diet and deportment
And other pointless forms of sacrifice
Conversation? Wit? I am a doubter
Manners? Charm?
They’re no way to impress
so forget the inner me, observe the outer
I am what I wear and how I dress
Marissa is 15-years old. The topic of modesty comes up quite frequently in our home. While I do sometimes talk to her about what kind of boy she is trying to attract, the “main point” of our conversations never is my telling my daughter that she is responsible to dress in a way that will keep boys from sinning or to encourage boys to grow spiritually. Sexual sin has been part of every culture no matter what style of dress was considered appropriate for women. It is not my daughter’s dress that causes men and boys to lust; it is their own sinful and fallen heart. Besides, my daughter wants to be attractive to the opposite sex. If I were to tell my daughter, “Don’t dress like that because men are attracted to women who dress like that,” my words would likely backfire. My daughter would want to dress more sensually because she wants attention from the boys her age. This is a normal part of shaking off her youth. Instead, I encourage my daughter to dress in a way that is not overly revealing, extravagant or attention-getting for her own spiritual and emotional well-being.
But the LORD said to Samuel, “Do not look at his appearance or at the height of his stature, because I have rejected him; for God {sees} not as man sees, for man looks at the outward appearance, but the LORD looks at the heart.”
~ 1 Samuel 16:7 (NAS)
I would love to place the emphasis on external looks squarely on the shoulders of our culture, but biblically that wouldn’t be true. All of us evaluate and judge people by what we see externally. I hope to teach my daughter that clothes, just like body language, tone of voice and posture communicate a message. Even if she thinks it isn’t fair, people will make assumptions about her based upon how she is dressed. More importantly, when Marissa tries to dress in a way that attracts attention to her outward appearance, she is drawing attention away from her inner self. Like the woman from Aida, she begins to focus on her clothing, her make-up and her hair while ignoring coversation, wit, manners and charm. Rather than studying the Bible, she studies the latest fashion magazine. Instead of being focused on what her Creator sees in her heart; she worries about whether the crowd is paying attention to the way she looks. Christians are supposed to be known for their love not for their wardrobe. Furthermore, dressing immodestly means that men pay attention to only a part of who she is. They concentrate on her body, perhaps comparing her to the unrealistic ideals portrayed by Hollywood and accepted as the “norm” by our culture. Focusing on her looks devalues her as a whole person.
The modesty I want to build in my daughter is a reflection of her heart attitude. Perhaps Webster said it best:
Modesty – That lowly temper which accompanies a moderate estimate of one’s own worth and importance. This temper when natural, springs in some measure from timidity, and in young and inexperienced persons, is allied to bashfulness and diffidence. In persons who have seen the world, and lost their natural timidity, modesty springs no less from principle than from feeling, and is manifested by retiring, unobtrusive manners, assuming less to itself than others are willing to yield, and conceding to others all due honor and respect, or even more than they expect or require. ~ Webster’s 1828 Dictionary
This weeks “In ‘Other’ Words” hosted by
Loni of Finding Joy in the Morning
Be sure to visit her site to read her thoughts and find links to other women’s interpretations of this quote ~












13 responses so far ↓
Miriam Pauline // 23 October 2007 at 3:22 am |
Although I agree that the main reason for modesty is not to keep others from sexual sin (they are responsible for keeping themselves pure), I see the author’s point that we can unintentionally make it more difficult. I am responsible for eating healthy and not falling into the sin of gluttony–but it is much easier if my friend puts out a fruit plate instead of a chocolate fountain! I want my girls to understand that they dress modestly out of respect for God and themselves–but I also will teach them that how they dress affects the boys around them. It is all in finding balance!
Welcome back to IOW!
lori@allyouhavetogive // 23 October 2007 at 5:11 am |
I am glad you joined this week, welcome back. I just want both my girls and my son to take accountability for who they are. If they say they are a Christian…then they need to understand that it comes with some responsibility, for BOTH of them! You are right to say that when a girl dresses immodestly, she is only presenting one part of herself, and sadly that may be the only part many see….fair, maybe not, but accountability again….
thank you for posting…I agree, its all in finding balance!:)
peace,
lori
hiddenart // 23 October 2007 at 8:52 am |
Thanks for posting the definition of modesty. I think the most important part of that definition is the “conceding to others all due honor and respect, or even more than they expect or require.” If we are thinking of others, we will dress and act thoughtfully towards them.
I’ve found the least modest person in our home is my son, not because of how he dresses, but because of his attention grabbing antics. He is learning to put others first, but when he was younger, he was very immodest with his actions.
I really believe our own preferences change when we put others first. Modesty does go much deeper than our choice of dress. I want my children to learn true modesty, not to learn to wear “modest” dress.
amanda
(((((HUGS))))) sandi // 23 October 2007 at 9:19 am |
OOOOHHHHH this is GOOD! THANK YOU for sharing it! What a refreshing perspective! (((((HUGS))))) sandi
Heather // 23 October 2007 at 10:59 am |
My goal is also to teach my girls and son to be modest in all things, including their behaviors.
Catch up « Hidden Art // 23 October 2007 at 11:04 am |
[...] And for a thought provoking post on modesty, visit Shanan Trail. [...]
Heather Cox // 23 October 2007 at 11:27 am |
I think you’ve made an interesting point here. We are each accoutable for our actions individually, but our behavior does influence others too, doesn’t it? How we dress as women is only half of the picture, but it does speak about the heart – dressing inappropriately communicates something deeper than immodesty…
Renae // 23 October 2007 at 12:09 pm |
I am glad your didn’t skip this. Your thoughts are refreshing. While we do need to consider our brothers and sisters, there is so much more involved. You have expressed it well.
Webster’s definition is wonderful. As we struggle against the knowledge of God, we loose the moderate view of ourselves and our respect for others. May God help us in this society that has tried sexualized everything, even clothes for little girls.
Loni // 23 October 2007 at 3:49 pm |
Thank you so much for sharing! It is a BIG picture with purity – dressing, just a portion of it. Thanks so much for your perspective. I hope that you will be a part of the book drawing as well. I think you will like it!
writeathome // 23 October 2007 at 7:30 pm |
I don’t know if you are familiar with homeschool e-store, but they have free products every week that you can download. This week they are offering a free lapbook for girls of all ages on modesty. If you’d like to check it out, the address is
http://www.homeschoolestore.com
Blessings,
Carol
titus2woman // 24 October 2007 at 10:52 am |
My cousins are AMAZING! Knocker is my cousin, and Lovely is my pet name for his wife. I can only remember seeing Knocker’s family once or twice growing up, got his family website from my Grandma a few years ago ( http://www.gaskinsfamily.com/ ), and WOW! We have sooo much in common~isn’t that amazing? I am VERY blessed to have them in my life, even though we get to see each other every few years. They still bless me in between~very, very neat! (Especially since my step-Mom just offered to buy us those latex things that prevent pregnancy. ACK!)
.
Please tell me more about Rushdoony! (((((HUGS))))) sandi
.
Sandi, I have sent you an email about why I expressed concerns about Rushdoony to the yahoo address you included in this comment.
Lori // 25 October 2007 at 8:35 am |
While I agree that dressing for oneself is the major reason to dress modestly, I also think that it is important to remember the people around you as well. I tell the girls that if you dress such that enticing body parts are visible or outlined, that that is what the boys will be looking at, not your eyes or your smile or the things that might point more to your inner self. I guess we’ll see how that works as they get older.
Michelle // 25 October 2007 at 11:00 am |
Until recently (when I had my surgery) I was always extremely self-conscious, and so I my modesty actually came from that. (I would have worn turtlenecks-year round if the weather would have allowed! – lol!)
I am blessed in the fact that modesty and femininity just seems to come ‘naturally’ to my oldest daughter. She loves to wear long* dresses and skirts. I pray that her younger sisters follow in her footsteps!
Also, we are using the ‘health and manners’ curriculum from Rod and Staff publishers, (an Amish/Mennonite publisher.) They have excellent instructions on Biblical modesty. I think the curriculum is intended for 4-6th graders, but because of Marissa’s ‘adjusted’ age, you might want to check it out (?)
Blessings,
Michelle