Shanan Trail

In Their Own Words

4 April 2008 · 13 Comments

Home Education Week“Do you still miss being in school?”

“Yes!”

“What do you miss? You get lots of time with your friends and it is time when you are free to talk and hang out rather than classroom time.”

“I want to be in drama and choir.”

I didn’t argue; I let Marissa be sad about missing out on those things that seem to be a normal part of the high school experience for many students. But in my heart I know that drama and choir would not have been part of Marissa’s high school experience. I fought hard to keep Marissa in choir during her last year of public school. Her IEP team wanted to take her out of choir and have her do an hour of “job training” with a “job coach.” (They wanted Marissa to clean the school while a paraprofessional followed her around.) Even if I was able to keep her in choir, she wouldn’t have been given the opportunities to sing that she has now. Her behavior was too unpredictable. What some of Marissa’s teachers wrote about Marissa in progress letters sent to me:

  • She needs to come to choir ready to sing. She needs to leave her frustrations in the “hall” and try to follow teacher directives in class. She is a VERY good singer. Great voice.
  • Marissa has become more and more off-task in choir.
  • She doesn’t have good coping skills.
  • Marissa frequently chooses to be off task.
  • She doesn’t bring required material to class so is not prepared to participate.
  • Marissa needs to develop skills and attitude for working effectively with others.
  • She needs assistance with a majority of the projects assigned due to not paying attention to directions. I honestly feel she has the ability to do the projects but waits until the last minute due to not focusing.
  • Marissa’s behavior is not appropriate in class or anywhere.

Marissa's school locker Marissa has partial Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. It takes her several seconds to process a simple direction. She cannot “ignore” the noise and activity in her environment. The hum of fluorescent light is a minor annoyance; a classmate writing with a dull pencil makes her cringe in the same way you and I might react to the squeal of chalk on a blackboard. She has developmental disabilities in areas related to paying attention to details, visual-motor coordination, concentration, abstract and visual problem solving. She scored in <5th percentile in object assembly. She once almost burned down our house assembling a lava lamp incorrectly.

So, let’s look at these real statements made by Marissa’s teachers and turn them into truths. Marissa does not choose to have atypical brain development due to prenatal exposure to alcohol; her damaged brain has difficulty staying focused and on task. Marissa cannot develop the skills and attitudes for working effectively with others. Marissa cannot leave her frustrations in the “hall.” Marissa’s behavior is very appropriate when her environment is controlled, expectations are clear and she is given adequate time to process instructions. She will probably always need someone else to help her advocate for an appropriate environment and explain expected or “normal” behavior. She needs adults in her environment who “honestly feel” that she can do the job after they have taken the time to make the instructions clear (and perhaps even writing them down). When a large task is assigned Marissa will need someone to help her look at the task and break it into smaller, more manageable parts. Marissa needs an uncluttered environment and help in organizing. She can’t bring what she needs to class if she can’t find things in her locker. Marissa cannot organize her locker; she needs help with locker assembly. The noise, chaos and activity level in the public school hallway is not “real life,” neither is lunch with 150 of your closest friends. In “real life” Marissa will not have 7 bosses who rotate every 45 minutes, each of whom has completely different expectations of her. 

Marissa would benefit from crisis counseling with a social worker or psychologist in the school when behavior problems emerge… Marissa should also be provided with the services of a full-time paraprofessional in the classroom setting with the exclusive duty of helping organize materials… Marissa should also be provided with individualized help in mathematics ~ Recommendations from neuropsychologist

Not one of these recommendations was ever implemented.

Related: See what it feels like to have FAS! Take this “fun” FAS Stimulation Test Analysis! Make sure the volume of your computer is turned up.

In Their Own Words is a part of Home Education Week!
Check Dana’s blog for links to other homeschooler’s stories!

Categories: Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder · Homeschool

13 responses so far ↓

  • Dana // 4 April 2008 at 12:10 am | Reply

    Thank you for sharing that bit of insight into your daughter’s world. And praise God she has a wonderful mother like you to step in to make sure she gets what she needs.

  • Heidi // 4 April 2008 at 12:12 am | Reply

    I’m going to have to come back tomorrow to take that test – - it’s a little past midnight and everyone else is sleeping – - don’t want to wake them with the speakers on. :)
    So glad that Marissa is finally getting the help she needs!
    Thanks for shring your story!

  • Ellen // 4 April 2008 at 12:27 am | Reply

    It is so neat that you are homeschooling Marissa. It’s hard when you know that you’re doing the right thing for your daughter, but she doesn’t understand. My 11-year-old daughter thinks I am so mean for not letting her go to a real school. I don’t want to hurt her feelings, so I spare her the truth. But the truth is that she is at a 3rd grade reading level instead of 5th. Our local school would have stuck her in the Special Ed class because that is what they do with all the kids that can’t keep up. (I know the Special Ed teacher.) She has buck teeth from sucking her fingers for so long and the kids would make fun of her. Plus, she has started developing physical sooner than other girls her age. I think that school would have permanently hurt her emotionally and I’m sparing her from that pain.

  • Stacy (Aussie in America) // 4 April 2008 at 12:39 am | Reply

    You are doing a wonderful thing by bringing your daughter home. She is blessed to have mother like you.
    Stacy

  • Kim // 4 April 2008 at 4:03 am | Reply

    Thanks for sharing about your daughter. You are doing a great work in her life. The rewards will be amazing!

  • jen // 4 April 2008 at 6:32 am | Reply

    You are so right. I have four home right now and trying to get the nerve to remove three more. One of them is very artistic and is hispanic. I don’t think she will be allowed to take higher level art classes or spanish.

    jen

  • Heather Young // 4 April 2008 at 9:13 am | Reply

    I do not have FAS but I struggled with similar things due to my specific learning disability . In fact the constant noise drove me to distraction, and trying to take a test with the fluorescent lights and the scraping of pencils, the little cough here and there, the sighs, and all the stuff. It was awful. I couldn’t take a test well until college when they finally tested me and said I could take the tests in a separate quiet room with just the professor. Suddenly I went from C’s and D’s to straight As.

    I often deal with similar struggles with my girls who due to neurological issues, allergies, and LD would not be able to do many of the things they love to do at home and think they could do better at school. My girls would both be in special ed and would be the bane of many teachers. Yet at home they are smart and have so many things they are good at. It is so very worth it.

  • kari // 4 April 2008 at 9:28 am | Reply

    You do so much to help people understand FASD. Thank you.

    And bless you for the mom you are to Marissa. ~Kari

  • Bobbie-Jo // 4 April 2008 at 12:30 pm | Reply

    What a great test. Even though I knew what I was doing, my heart fluttered at the word “fail”. Very powerful.

    Did the school know that Marissa was affected by alcohol when they wrote those comments on her report card? Seems a heartless thing to write about somoeone who has a LD.

    Marissa did not have a diagnosis of FASD at the time. The doctor that first evaluated her would not diagnose her because I didn’t have confirmation of prenatal exposure. I had a second-hand report of drug and alcohol use from Marissa’s aunt who lived near her mother while she was pregnant and had custody of Marissa’s half-brother, but the doctor wanted a statement from the mother. Her diagnosis was confirmed the summer after she left school. By that time, Marissa had contact with her mom and I just asked her what she had used during pregnancy. However, Marissa has been identified as LD since she was evaluated with the DIAL-R in preschool. Every developmental and IQ test has shown significant developmental delays. And, you are right, saying those things about a child with a DD is heartless.

  • Bobbie // 4 April 2008 at 1:02 pm | Reply

    Marissa is blessed to be able to sing “while” doing her school work without chastisement. I am so glad she has a Christian outlet for her amazing Gift!
    And just so you know, most teenagers even those without FASD wish they were at school at one time or another and it usually has to do with hanging out with friends at lunch time. If they had a clue what it is like to be lectured at all day and do homework ALL night, they wouldn’t leave home for all the world.

    Please tell Marissa how blessed we are that she is homeschooled so we get to hear her sing!

    Because of Jesus, Bobbie

  • Heidi // 4 April 2008 at 1:17 pm | Reply

    I came back to take the test – - wow – - was that frustrating!!!
    Thanks for sharing what it is like in Marissa’s world.

  • Sombra // 4 April 2008 at 5:51 pm | Reply

    How do you see Marissa coping as a Mother? I know a family where there is a young man with FAS, and his mother raises his son for him. He’s great at the loving, and the taking care of responsibilities of putting to bed and feeding – SO LONG as his mother is there to over see it all and tell him to do it. She never leaves that baby at home alone with his dad.. I don’t think she leaves the dad at home alone either.

    BTW, the biological mother also has FAS and has chosen not to participate in the raising, though she was willing to go through pregnancy and birth. The baby is perfectly healthy.

    There is one woman with FAS whose husband is neurotypical. She tells people that her husband raised the kids and she just played with them. I think this is how Marissa would be with kids. Adults with FAS seem to do better if they embrace their brain and/or marry someone who advocates for them. Helping Marissa where she needs it and treating her as a normal adult in the areas where she is “normal” requires quite a bit of tight-rope walking. It will take a special man to fulfill this role.

  • Renae // 4 April 2008 at 11:04 pm | Reply

    I am always touched by your posts. I’m so glad that Marissa has you for her mother.

Leave a Comment